How to allocate arrays of C ++ objects with memory allocation?

I see a problem with the new [] operator:

#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdio.h>

class V4 { public:
    float v[ 4 ];
    V4() {}
    void *operator new( size_t sz ) { return aligned_alloc( 16, sz ); } 
    void *operator new[]( size_t sz ) { printf( "sz: %zu\n", sz ); return aligned_alloc( 16, sz ); }
    void operator delete( void *p, size_t sz ) { free( p ); }
  //void operator delete[]( void *p, size_t sz ) { free( p ); }
};

class W4 { public:
    float w[ 4 ];
    W4() {}
    void *operator new( size_t sz ) { return aligned_alloc( 16, sz ); } 
    void *operator new[]( size_t sz ) { printf( "sz: %zu\n", sz ); return aligned_alloc( 16, sz ); }
    void operator delete( void *p, size_t sz ) { free( p ); }
    void operator delete[]( void *p, size_t sz ) { free( p ); }
};

int main( int argc, char **argv ) { 

    printf( "sizeof( V4 ): %zu\n", sizeof( V4 ));
    V4 *p = new V4[ 1 ];
    printf( "p: %p\n", p );

    printf( "sizeof( W4 ): %zu\n", sizeof( W4 ));
    W4 *q = new W4[ 1 ];
    printf( "q: %p\n", q );

    exit(0);
}

It produces:

$ g++ -Wall main.cpp && ./a.out
sizeof( V4 ): 16
sz: 16
p: 0x55be98a10030
sizeof( W4 ): 16
sz: 24
q: 0x55be98a10058

Why does the selection size increase to 24 when I include the delete [] operator? This spins my lined malloc.

$ g++ --version
g++ (Debian 7.2.0-18) 7.2.0
Copyright (C) 2017 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
This is free software; see the source for copying conditions.  There is NO
warranty; not even for MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.

From looking at other issues, it seems that an additional 8 bytes can be used to store the size of the array. Even if this is the expected behavior, why is it called by the delete [] operator, and what is the correct procedure for allocating size-aligned arrays?

EDIT , , , . , , . , std::vector. , , 16 , , 8 16 . delete [] free(). , , (C runtime?) ( 8 ), 16- Vector4s.

EDIT , , , .

EDIT , , , 8 delete []:

#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdint.h>

class W16 { public:

    float w[ 16 ];
    W16() {}
    void *operator new( size_t sz ) { return aligned_alloc( 16, sz ); } 
    void *operator new[]( size_t sz ) {
        size_t r = sz % sizeof( W16 );
        size_t ofs = sizeof( W16 ) - r;
        size_t _sz = sz + ofs;
        void *p1 = aligned_alloc( sizeof( W16 ), _sz );
        void *p2 = ((uint8_t *) p1) + ofs;
        printf( "sizeof( W16 ): %zx, sz: %zx, r: %zx, ofs: %zx, _sz: %zx\np1: %p\np2: %p\n\n", sizeof( W16 ), sz, r, ofs, _sz, p1, p2 );
        return p2;
    }
    void operator delete( void *p, size_t sz ) { free( p ); }
    void operator delete[]( void *p, size_t sz ) {
    void *p1 = ((int8_t*) p) + 8 - sizeof( W16 );
        printf( "\np2: %p\np1: %p", p, p1 );
        free( p1 );
    }
};

int main( int argc, char **argv ) {

    printf( "sizeof( W16 ): %zx\n", sizeof( W16 ));
    W16 *q = new W16[ 16 ];
    printf( "&q[0]: %p\n", &q[0] );
    delete[] q;
}

:

$ g++ -Wall main.cpp && ./a.out 
sizeof( W16 ): 40
sizeof( W16 ): 40, sz: 408, r: 8, ofs: 38, _sz: 440
p1: 0x559876c68080
p2: 0x559876c680b8

&q[0]: 0x559876c680c0

p2: 0x559876c680b8
p1: 0x559876c68080

EDIT . , "" , , .

+6
1

, :

#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdint.h>

inline void *array_alloc( size_t sz_obj, size_t sz_req ) {
    size_t r = sz_req % sz_obj;
    size_t ofs = sz_obj - r;
    size_t sz = sz_req + ofs;
    void *p1 = aligned_alloc( sz_obj, sz );
    void *p2 = (void*) (((uintptr_t ) p1) + ofs);
  //printf( "sz_obj: %zx, sz_req: %zx, r: %zx, ofs: %zx, sz: %zx\np1: %p\np2: %p\n\n", sz_obj, sz_req, r, ofs, sz, p1, p2 );
    return p2;
}

inline void array_free( size_t sz_obj, void *p2 ) {
    void *p1 = (void*) (((uint8_t*)p2) - (((uintptr_t)p2) % sz_obj));
  //printf( "\np2: %p\np1: %p", p2, p1 );
    free( p1 );
}

class W16 { public:

    float w[ 16 ];
    W16() {}
    void *operator new( size_t sz ) { return aligned_alloc( 16, sz ); } 
    void *operator new[]( size_t sz ) { return array_alloc( sizeof( W16 ), sz ); }
    void operator delete( void *p, size_t sz ) { free( p ); }
    void operator delete[]( void *p, size_t sz ) { array_free( sizeof( W16 ), p ); }
};

int main( int argc, char **argv ) {
  //printf( "sizeof( W16 ): %zx\n", sizeof( W16 ));
    W16 *q = new W16[ 16 ];
    printf( "&q[0]: %p\n", &q[0] );
    delete[] q;
}

EDIT n.m., .

+1

All Articles