Are reCAPTCHA CAPTCHA harder or just me

Question

As I tested sites, I found that reCAPTCHA is getting harder to read. Is it just me or others who have this problem?

Along with this, I had a user this morning complaining about getting a character from the Bristol Pound in their reCAPTCHA. Of course, the user did not know what to do, although I have a message saying that they can click the reboot / update icon to get a new CAPTCHA.

Unfortunately, this implementation on the site is often used by people over 60, so it’s more difficult to confuse CAPTCHA, but there are still a lot of people trying to create spam on the site.

Answer 1

Despite the opinions presented so far, I really like the reCAPTCHA system. I like this mainly because I believe that he manages to solve two problems at once: verify human identity and help digitize records (for those of you who don’t know here why he uses 2 words and not one: reCAPTCHA philosophy

Therefore, I urge all of you to try the reCAPTCHA tests as often as you can, because you really help for good reasons.

Answer 2

Worst of all are case sensitive. L, l, I, o O 0?

Answer 3

It's hard for me to read most Captcha, but I agree that reCAPTCHA is a particular nuisance.

Answer 4

Yes, Captchas are getting harder to read.

CAPTCHA image http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/1253/picture3rs8.png

I can’t find the link right now, but I find that Microsoft Passport (MSN and Hotmail) are the most difficult to break.

The problem is that whenever the software improves upon detecting text, the text becomes more difficult to read.

The irony, I think, is that CAPTCHA means “Turing’s fully automated public test to talk about computers and people,” but computers will not go to the end and they will become too difficult for most people to read. At this time, they will disappear and another version of CAPTCHA will be used.

Perhaps CAPTCHAS uses the Google Image Labeling System based on CAPTCHAS photos?

Answer 5

Ironically, because while computers are certainly getting smarter, people are probably getting dumb too.

Answer 6

I think they are getting harder, I know that I usually fail every captcha that I try at least once, sometimes twice. However, there are good alternatives. For example, Jeff Appleby displays nine photos and gives a text description for you to select three of them (scroll down to the comment form).

Such a system would be very accessible for the profiles you described (photos can be quite large). It is also much easier to implement.

Answer 7

Definitely getting harder. My very last had something completely indistinguishable, next to the "written" upside down.

Answer 8

I find reCAPTCHA the absolute worst for ease of use. I often avoid sites that use them.

I do not mind that sites should do these tests, but they should not be so nearly impossible to understand.

Answer 9

Perhaps reCAPTCHA, when it begins to work on words that people get correctly, begins to process tougher and tougher words "unknkown" as people filter out all the lungs?

Answer 10

I have been identified several times as a non-person on a blog Blog overflow blog . Now I just keep asking for new captchas until I get one that I can read. Usually only ~ 3 attempts are required.

Update:. According to Ben Maurer, chief engineer of reCAPTCHA, who commented on my blog about this , more than 96% of RECAPTHA are solved correctly. So maybe we, as a group, are just getting dumb?

Answer 11

reCAPTCHA will always get complicated.

Since they create reCAPTCHA break tools, they will use the same technology to help digitize the text, so only those that the latest technology cannot read will be used as CAPTCHA.

His spy versus spy, besides his winning victory for reCAPTCHA and human knowledge.

The only problem they are faced with is that they have a reader who is so good that they never fail, reCAPTCHA will no longer work, but it would be a good problem to digitize human knowledge.

Answer 12

I think that eventually CAPTCHA will cease to be feasible, and there will be some kind of universally recognized "passport" system for websites. Some kind of account for which you pay a couple of dollars, and it identifies you as a person when you subscribe to the site.

Then, if you start using this account for your spam bots, you can get a ban everywhere. Sites can even retroactively clear messages based on these inhibitions. shrug just a thought

Answer 13

Quite a few boot sites just stopped using captchas. All you really need to do is register the client's IP address and stop giving them access in x minutes.

The same can be used for passwords. Did the user enter the password in his password 3 times? Wait five minutes to try again. And give them the opportunity to update it by sending them an email.

About time we will get rid of these captcha. Computers and algorithms have become fast enough to crack even the most complex. Although this only upsets people.

Answer 14

Yes. It is getting harder. If everyone understood how reCAPTCHA works, everyone should go through even with an unreadable word. reCAPTCHA always shows 2 words: one of the words reCAPTCHA knows its ASCII representation through OCR, the other - you may fail because reCAPTCHA does not know the correct answer. When I find reCAPTCHA too complex, I simply type "verydifficultword" along with the read word.

Answer 15

What you should remember about ReCAPTCHA is that they are images actually scanned from real books and articles. So you should be aware that funky punctuation and more can do this - these are not just words. For example, I saw partial words that end with a hyphen (which, obviously, happened at the end of the line), as well as dollar signs, numbers (for example, 1. Something), etc.

I find, if you remember the origin, it draws much more meaning and is easier to solve.

Also interesting, you only need to get one of the words reCAPTCHA correctly, because the other is used to help in digitizing. However, you will not know what is. :)

Answer 16

There is something worse on the Internet than

captcha.

alt text http://img227.imageshack.us/img227/5972/11111111.gif

( megaupload "captcha")

Answer 17

Yes, it is getting harder. Whatever is good, it should be helpful. I tried 3 or 4 times on their audio image and failed every time. Although captchas try to solve the real problem, for those who do not see the captcha image and must rely on audio patches, this is a big problem. In addition, not all sites that use captcha provide audio options. In any case, I think we will have to continue to prove to these machines that we are truly people for a long time.