How to get input from a specific form using the HtmlAgility Pack? Lang: C # .net

Question

The code can explain this problem much better than I can. I also included alternative methods that I was trying to do. If possible, explain why these other methods also do not work. I ran out of ideas, and, unfortunately, there are few examples for HtmlAgilityPack. I am currently looking through the documentation looking for more ideas.

One thing I noticed is the .nextSibling property, and I thought I could use the while loop to go through the form until I find the next sibling or the end of the form.

Anyway, here is the code:

using System; using System.Collections.Generic; using System.Linq; using System.Text; using HtmlAgilityPack; using System.Collections; namespace ConsoleApplication1 { class Program { static void Main(string[] args) { string source = @" <form name='form1' action='action1' method='method1' id='id1'> <input type='text1.1' name='name1.1' value='value1.1' /> <input type='text1.2' name='name1.2' value='value1.2' /> </form> <form name='form2' action='action2' method='method2' id='id2'> <input type='text2.1' name='name2.1' value='value2.1' /> <input type='text2.2' name='name2.2' value='value2.2' /> </form> "; List<HtmlAttribute> formAttributes = new List<HtmlAttribute>();//this is what i'm wanting to get for the current form. /** * I want to end up with a list that has * Name: type Value: text1.1 * Name: name Value: 1.1 * Name: value Value: value1.1 * Name: type Value: text1.2 * Name: name Value: name1.2 * Name: value Value: value1.2 * but I am ending up with the 2nd forms values as well * */ HtmlDocument htmlDoc = new HtmlDocument(); htmlDoc.LoadHtml(source); var forms = htmlDoc.DocumentNode.Descendants("form"); foreach (var form in forms) { Console.WriteLine(form.Attributes[0].Value); //simple writes the form name to the console to keep track of things HtmlNodeCollection inputs = form.SelectNodes("/input"); // gets all the inputs in the selected form, or so I thought. This is where the problem lies. Result: Shows both forms inputs. //HtmlNodeCollection inputs = form.SelectNodes("//input"); // not the best at xpath, but perhaps this could make a difference? Result: no difference //var inputs = form.Elements("input"); // Maybe the inputs are referred to as elements? Result: shows no input outerhtml at all. foreach (var input in inputs) //this has all 4 inputs from both forms. I only want it to have 2 inputs from the selected form. { Console.WriteLine(input.OuterHtml); List<HtmlAttribute> attributes = new List<HtmlAttribute>(); attributes = input.Attributes.ToList<HtmlAttribute>(); foreach (var att in attributes) { //add attributes to allattributes list code that will be done once problem of getting only inputs for specified form is fixed } } // here comes an alternate method! Edit: Didn't work :'( //var inputs = form.Descendants("input"); // perhaps using the "Descendants class will make a difference. Result: Nope, didn't have any items at all! //IEnumerator e = inputs.GetEnumerator(); //while (e.MoveNext()) //{ // Console.WriteLine("input: " + e.Current); //} Console.WriteLine(); // Simply making everything look pretty with a newline after each form name/input outerhtml display. } Console.Read(); } } } 

Answer 1

I found the answer! Take a look at the code below as it contains a solution and explanation! :)

 using System; using System.Collections.Generic; using System.Linq; using System.Text; using HtmlAgilityPack; using System.Collections; namespace ConsoleApplication1 { class Program { static void Main(string[] args) { string source = @" <form name='form1' action='action1' method='method1' id='id1'> <input type='text1.1' name='name1.1' value='value1.1' /> <input type='text1.2' name='name1.2' value='value1.2' /> </form> <form name='form2' action='action2' method='method2' id='id2'> <input type='text2.1' name='name2.1' value='value2.1' /> <input type='text2.2' name='name2.2' value='value2.2' /> </form> "; List<HtmlAttribute> formAttributes = new List<HtmlAttribute>(); IEnumerable<HtmlNode> inputs; /* * The line below is the major reason that this solution "worked" and the other didn't * */ HtmlNode.ElementsFlags.Remove("form"); /* * I was going through the HtmlAgilityPack forum, and stumbled upon this little tidbit of info: * * "This is because by default, Forms are parsed as empty nodes - this is because forms are allowed to overlap other elements in the HTML spec. In other words, the following is technically legal HTML, even though it gives us developer hives: <table> <form> <some input elements> </table> </form> Here, the form overlaps the closing of the table and when properly rendered, will be contained inside the table. Since HtmlDocument attempts to allow this as valid without automatically correcting the HTML, HtmlDocument by default makes no attempt to populate the child nodes of the form. Ok. All that is merely an introduction. You can get around this default behavior by adding the following line: HtmlNode.ElementsFlags.Remove("form"); before you make ANY use of HtmlDocument. This will allow it to parse the nodes of the form, but it sacrifices the ability of the form to overlap other nodes. It will force the form to be closed properly." * * HtmlAgilityPack didn't put the inputs as the childnode of each form because of "technically legal HTML" that could mess things up a bit, * so the only thing I had to do is remove the element flag! Enjoy the code below, it should be pretty self explanatory. * */ HtmlDocument htmlDoc = new HtmlDocument(); htmlDoc.OptionOutputAsXml = true; htmlDoc.OptionAutoCloseOnEnd = true; htmlDoc.LoadHtml(source); var forms = htmlDoc.DocumentNode.Descendants("form"); foreach (var form in forms) { inputs = form.ChildNodes .Where<HtmlNode>(a => a.OriginalName.Contains("input")); // woo hoo, finally figuring out what linq is. Sort of like mysql when I was coding php! Console.WriteLine(form.Attributes[0].Value + " attributes:" + Environment.NewLine + "------------------"); foreach (var input in inputs) { IEnumerable<HtmlAttribute> attributes; attributes = input.Attributes; foreach (var att in attributes) { Console.WriteLine("Name: " + att.Name + Environment.NewLine + "Value: " + att.Value + Environment.NewLine); formAttributes.Add(att); } } Console.WriteLine(); // Simply making everything look pretty with a newline after each form name/input outerhtml display. } Console.Read(); } } }